Skip to content
Plainly Brief provides accessible legal analysis and explan…

Neither Saint Nor Sinner: The Baroque Master’s Vibrant Portrait of Magdalene.

A female figure tilts her head backwards. Her eyes are shut, lips sealed, yet she is fully conscious. Sporting rosy cheeks and vermilion lips, her lustrous honey-colored hair reflects the glow from a nearby candle, bathed in a luminous aura in an predominantly gloomy room. Her attire includes a lace-trimmed chemise—falling off one arm to expose alabaster skin—to a heavy yellow and purple cloth. She appears solitary, unaware of any observer, existing in a state of profound liberation.

A Significant New Purchase

This woman is Mary Magdalene “in ecstasy”, painted in the seventeenth century by the renowned painter Artemisia. Freshly purchased by the National Gallery of Art in the U.S. capital, it is set to go on public view from late February. It represents the institution’s first acquisition of a work by Gentileschi, and curator a leading scholar has written that it portrays the saint as “not in a state of penance or anguish”. This is an crucial distinction, for ages, her representation has been formed not only by scripture but mythologized and merged by influential male figures.

“The most versatile woman in sacred iconography,” as one scholar stated.

Study images of her and you will see a thinker, orator, disciple, and observer; weeping at the base of the Cross, anointing Christ’s feet, or looking heavenward—often repenting with pearl-like tears and, conveniently, exposing her bosom. At times identified by a alabaster jar or a red robe—unlike the Madonna’s azure—she is commonly known today as a prostitute, despite not a single scriptural account describing her as such.

The Layers of Interpretation

“In reality, we do not truly know who she was,” said the expert. “Consequently, numerous strata of meaning have fallen upon her. The transformations she undergoes, both visually but in story, devotionally, theologically, are as closely tied to societal views and religious changes as they are to belief.” What then do we understand?

She is mentioned in the Gospels twelve times. Initially, she has evil spirits expelled from her; subsequently, she is seen at Christ’s execution and is the primary witness to see his resurrection. It is she who proclaims the “gospel”. Her sexual and immoral reputation can largely be traced to a sermon given in the 500s by Gregory I, who merged her with Mary of Bethany and an unnamed sinner who washed Christ’s feet with her tears.

In lumping them into one, he effectively “invented” the penitent fallen woman—a narrative further expanded by subsequent church fathers and Middle Ages texts. Artists took note, and in a predominantly illiterate but image-savvy world, this was influential. The “evil spirits” became the “cardinal vices”, establishing her primary narrative as one of moral lapse and subsequent redemption—concretised in paintings and sculptures that continue to influence perceptions today.

A Legacy of Suffering and Sexualization

From Donatello’s emaciated, skeletal Magdalene wringing her hands in penitence, to Caravaggio’s seventeenth-century portrayal of her drained of color and near death—not to mention yet another artist’s partially clothed, rapturous saint supported by angels. Her image has often been diminished sexually. Albrecht Dürer’s engraving presented her coyly, with cascading hair draping her unclothed body, while Titian’s version gazes heavenward, with glassy eyes and strategically placed hands revealing her breasts.

It seems, anguish and sexualization were the dominant poles in her depiction: she could act as a warning against sin, be the exemplar for repentance, while providing artists a pretext to paint the female form masked as devotion. This “fallen woman redeemed” narrative persisted for hundreds of years—so profoundly that institutions called “Magdalene laundries” subjected women into unpaid labor, a practice that astonishingly ended a mere thirty years ago.

Through a Woman’s Eyes

But what if there was a different facet to her narrative? Imagine if her tale could be one of spiritual awakening and metamorphosis, where she was pictured as vibrant, joy, and sublimity? Essentially, what if we saw her via the lens of a female artist?

That is what Gentileschi accomplishes. This Magdalene is not posing for the viewer; she is without tears, not repenting, without shame, not objectified, and not dictating a sermon. Rather, she has rosy cheeks and is, as described, “vibrantly living … in the grip of divine joy”. An expert remarked that Gentileschi “imbues Mary Magdalene with an dynamic vitality”.

“It is an ecstasy painting, but it’s not her instant of repentance. It’s a moment of divine meeting … described sometimes as if it’s the finest physical experience … the most profound orgasm she could ever have. It’s aesthetic, it’s bodily, it’s sexual, it’s transcendent. You are lifted beyond oneself to a higher level.”

Frequently, when women portray scriptural or mythological women, they present them not as passive, sinful, shameful, or subordinate, but as agentic, multifaceted, and with wills of their own: “Females with a capital ‘Woman’”.

Part of a Broader Cultural Movement

Thus, while this new acquisition may finally be correcting a representational imbalance at the gallery, its importance extends further. It alters not just how we perceive biblical and mythological women, but also the female experience at large.

This view is one the Catholic church in time recognized. In 1969, it formally affirmed her canonical definition as a faithful follower rather than a sinful repenter. More recently 2016, the pontiff elevated her ranking to “apostle to the apostles”, marking a day in July as her feast day. This indicates that, while institutions evolve, perspectives are shifting. This new purchase—of a woman liberated from a patriarchal gaze, living for her own sake, without anguish and not exploited—is part of a greater shift towards equality.

Written by

Michelle Hunter

A former corporate attorney turned legal educator, passionate about demystifying law for the public.

Plainly Brief

Type to search articles.